Happiness Redefined?
A concept like happiness—or freedom—poses problems for definition. Abstract words like these are quite open to interpretation and have no single real-world referent. For some, happiness is based solely on being part of a loving family that is safe and well provided for. For others, happiness is rooted in material possessions or power. Although people may have quite different interpretations of such concepts, in our everyday conversations we seem content with a general understanding of meaning, accepting that any utterance is open to some variation depending on the person speaking.
Briefly, there are two types of happiness: temporary and permanent. But by all measures, happiness is transient. There is no such thing as permanent or absolute happiness. It is a feeling—or rather, a series of feelings—born from the loss of mental consciousness. Happiness is the accumulation of many good activities, through which your mind becomes engaged. These many good actions sustain a good life. Physical or external happiness brings internal happiness.
Why GNH is NOT Successful
Why are we not happy? All of us are born blank—clear as crystal, with a simple mind. There is no question of "what is life?" when we begin. But once we grow, everything pours in: religion, culture, society, norms, fears. We are tuned like machines to act. Our lives are conformed and ruled. I have briefly considered some hitches, with references to particular consistencies.
The First Obstruction: Religion
The first obstruction to happiness is religion. A slightly deeper understanding of the spiritual world brings greater unhappiness, just as greater knowledge subsumes a major portion of happiness. Religion teaches concocted falseness about life—sufferings, sorrows, sins, death—that alters our lives and every action. Religion corrupts with many unrealistic imaginations and theories, and creates fears not only in this life but also in a next life, troubled by imagination. On the other hand, you feel compelled to follow the dogmas of religion from fear of excommunication by parents and community. You believe that religion is the only secret and your own way to reach heaven. Since religions say all are born as sinners, and if you don't purify in this life, you believe you will be condemned to hell by God. Thus you live under constant fear about whether your works are right according to religion. Your mind is filled with worry and anxiety about hell. So your life becomes fearful of living. It truly confuses your existence. For example, phallicism adds shame, and people secretly spit on and demean its values.
Religion teaches you to be like the Buddha, Lord Krishna, Christ, and so on. When you fail to attain that, you hate yourself and slowly become bad and corrupted, thinking you are not worthy to live. These doubts and superstitious beliefs ultimately dehumanize you. When you hate yourself, you hate your partner, your family, people, animals, your community, and society. You carry a cesspool of hatred. And hatred leads to an unhappy life.
The concept and search for emptiness in religion in turn fills your mind—making you god-fearing, not god-loving. You tend to suffer in real life because you live in the imagination, a world outside this world, infecting imaginary pains and suffering onto your surroundings, to a great extent. You are caught up in doubt. You are afraid to make decisions. You skip from one belief to another, always doubting whether you have found the right path. For example, a desire to be in an imaginary perfected heaven taunts real life more, and diminishes when you imagine hell. You become increasingly aware that your mind trembles between religion and life, likes and dislikes, pain and pleasure. This is the basis of the problem of suffering, and you distort the very nature of life. Religion sucks your life. There is no transcending happiness.
Consider this: a drunkard is often a happy man. He lives in the moment. He enjoys. He has no past, no present, no future—a buoyant life swings him with laughter. The effect of drugs can produce a state of happiness, but if you know you are drugged, your happiness fades. Religion is like drugs. If you don't know how to incorporate it into your life, you bungle a good life.
The followers of religious sects, in my view, are often among the most despicable people in the world. Monks, suppose, are a miserable group of species on earth. They sneak out of monasteries and play snooker or caroms in the Hong Kong market in Thimphu. They rape. They commit all kinds of illegal acts. The first tobacco offender in Bhutan was a monk. And he deserved three years in prison because he set a bad example for good people.
I have defined happiness as a collection of happy activities. Yet religion forbids many pleasurable, enjoyable activities. Where is happiness if these activities are not allowed? For example, religion prohibits playing degor or archery, or imposes a set of principles if one indulges too much. These activities provide short-term joy, and the recurrence of short-term joys is the essence of long-term inner peace and happiness. Happiness is also a manifestation of external or physical happiness. External happiness brings internal happiness.
Happiness is lost when there is no good love. And religion forbids this too. Where is happiness without attachment, affection, love, or passion? The cruel intention of religion is to isolate you, destroy your self-worth, and separate you from personal love and affection. Personal love and happiness radiate to others. Religion does not reflect life; it does not show good ways; it never touches life. In fact, it creates the illusion of separateness—the illusion that there is you and a totally separate other.
Religious superiority widens gaps and builds tensions. Some religious sects think their religion is true and superior and all others are false. For example, Muslims believe Islam is the true religion and all others are false. Because of these differences, religious tensions, racisms, gaps, problems, and violence are widespread. The perennial conflicts between Muslims and Buddhists in Burma make thousands of families unhappy. British colonizers used Christian missionaries to colonize people's minds. The history of wars tells us that many wars are based on religious rifts and conflicts. For example, the religious atrocities between Sunnis and Shiites tear thousands of lives apart. The early European conflict between Protestant Christians and the Catholic Church from 1524 to 1648, and the Crusades, are further examples of religiously motivated wars.
I am not against any religion per se, but I am against its principles, its sects, its confining customs. Religion confines and harms one internally rather than alleviating life. It prohibits the freedom to do and enjoy, even when no one else is harmed. I am against its superfluous interpretations, especially those coming from half-baked religious practitioners.
The Second Obstruction: Society
The second obstruction to a happy life is society and the people around you. To live life according to the control of others, to rely on others' opinions, to conform, and not to be true to yourself—this is so paltry that you lead a pitiful life. You mask your face. You imitate the pattern. You have no creative pattern of your own. You never improve because of these people and society. They devalue individualism. It is difficult to mind your own business, think about yourself, believe in yourself, and lead a happy life. For example, you may like fashion and want to learn about it. That is your interest. You will do something different from your villagers. But your environment lacerates you. You must walk the same trodden path. You don't have your own small path. What a heck? There is no "self." Instead, you live in a mix of anxious shadows—shame, unworthiness, rage, mistrust, rejection, desolation—that simmer below the surface of your face value.
True happiness is self-reliant. It listens to oneself, not to society, not to others' bullshit—not to your neighbor or your environment. Last weekend, I watched a gripping movie, The Stoning of Soraya M. This true story is a tale of horrific injustice from a feigned society. It represents the stilled practices and norms of society in many Middle Eastern countries. The story occurs in a village where stoning as capital punishment drives away the happiness of women and men alike. Zahra's revelation to French journalists about the stoning of Soraya is a revolution against the secret evils of a sadistic, misogynist society that fabricates superstitious beliefs to terrorize and brutally execute a woman.
The Third Obstruction: Material Development
The third obstruction to happiness is material development. Development materially does not bring happiness. For example, the expansion of road networks harms the environment. Wanting happiness is not about doing away with desire, but about being self-contained. Self-reliance does not mean economic self-reliance alone. It is individual self-satisfaction, mental self-realization. You are poor because you think you are poor, or because you cannot save what you get. What do riches and position do for a life? It is just a psyche. The basic way of living a life is enough to be happy. There are many clutches to be freed—hindrances to our happiness. You want things, and it is okay to want things and to want to succeed, but tell yourself that you will be happy even without them.
Development like technology and media instead brings more depression. For example, you tend to imitate movies, which are reflections but not real life. You hunt for a movie-like life and feel depressed when you cannot achieve it. Development pushes you further away from life. Social media like Facebook brings more harm. It not only erodes human values like love, relationship, and ethics, but it also kills a lot of time. At a New Year's riverside family gathering, I saw a man engaged with his laptop on Facebook the entire day. His family connection was completely lost. Family concerns were given no importance.
Happiness is Also Good Relationship
Happy wife, happy life—or happy husband, happy life. A virtuous relationship, a good sex life, good understanding—these make a happy life. They are basic sources of happiness at times. Good relations include not only your family but also everything that surrounds you: your dog or animals, your home, your kitchen garden, your friends, your neighbors, your environment—everything around you.
Worry about your own family, your own sons and daughters at home, rather than worrying about the Darfur war or Somalia's hunger. You worry so much more about the outside than your inside world, bringing unhappy pictures into your life, to your spouse, to your family. You watch more programs on television than you watch your family or neighbor. You talk more about the world's problems than your own family matters or matters with your neighbor. You barricade your neighbor with a wall. You bother more about other buildings than your own. You don't know your next-door people. You create such an awkward environment where you live. The world has fallen apart. City life is fast sweeping into rural country. You compare so much: you compare your spouse with another, you compare your relationship with others', you compare your children with movies or some other "best" children, you compare life as a whole. You live in a world of comparison, and when you compare, you compare what is not in you. Sometimes, being self-righteous, being individualistic, and being contained are the true ways of living.
The GNH Pillars Themselves
The Gross National Happiness pillars themselves are obvious manifestations of immeasurable deterrence to happiness. To bring equitable and equal socio-economic development, sacrifices must be made to the environment, culture, and spiritual heritage. Equal economic development is not attainable—not even fair equality—if these pillars are strictly followed. For equality to exist, your mind must first be tamed. The preservation and promotion of cultural and spiritual heritage only help you go backward to the primitive. And they cannot be barred. Imported cultures make you happier and give you a sense of development and belonging. How many of you don't like to watch Hollywood movies? How many of you like to impress others with a typical foreign accent? How many of you don't want to pursue Western education? How many of you still want to read Kanjur and Tenjur in your room? How many of you want to adopt and change? The questions continue, and these questions are not recipes for happiness, but rather pillars to a happy life. The Countess of Blessington says, "There is no cosmetic for beauty like happiness." It is true.
You cannot be taught values, aesthetics, and spiritual traditions—the so-called pillars of happiness. They must be practiced on your own.
You cannot say governance is good governance. Your good governance will be another's bad government. Government and bureaucracy comprise many antagonistic characters and sinecure workers. The so-called upholders of rules and regulations are themselves perpetrators in the country. Recent political parties bray out false promises to woo voters. For example, the Druk Phuensum Tshogpa's prime minister asking unashamedly for kidu (royal benefaction) of Prado cars for themselves from the King is inappropriate. Kidu is only meant for the unfortunate poor. Is this good governance? On the pretext of keeping old customs and traditions, there is much corruption, nepotism, and sycophancy.
To have good governance, people work to the maximum trying to achieve it. A very bad life has to be lived to gain good governance. Tough National Assembly discussions project an image of governance. Civil rights movements, anti-corruption moves, fraternity, and equality are all sores of the human desire to change the system without changing themselves.
So What is Happiness?
The precept of happiness is being kind, loving, and true to yourself. In other words, it is self-loving, self-kindness, self-forgiveness, self-preserving, self-protection, and non-self-judgment. You need love and appreciation. But you cannot find them in others. You find them in yourself. You make yourself happy. Only then can you please others. Do first what pleases you without harming others. Build empathy and compassion within yourself, and this can ultimately lead to self-satisfaction, fearlessness, confidence, and strength against any other account.
So, happiness is no hue and cry about GNH parameters, religious dogmas, the outside world, comparison, or imaginary beliefs. It is simply the basic, necessary life of your own.
Bertrand Russell says in his book The Conquest of Happiness:
"A man who has once perceived, however temporarily and however briefly, what makes the greatness of a soul can no longer be happy if he allows himself to be petty, self-seeking, troubled by trivial misfortunes, dreading what fate may have in store for him. The man capable of the greatness of soul will open wide the windows of his mind, letting the winds blow freely upon it from every portion of the universe."
Note: This article is not entirely baseless; it is quite analytical. It is not so well researched but has argumentative aspects. The writer's view does not go against any individuals, sects, or the government, nor does it challenge any facts. But it is a personal defiance of the concepts described. The essay will be continued soon.